Where zodiac birthstones come from
The idea that each sign of the zodiac has a stone is old. The International Gem Society traces it to Josephus in the first century and St. Jerome in the fifth, who linked the twelve stones of the high priest’s breastplate with the twelve signs. The gem expert George F. Kunz, in his 1913 book on the lore of precious stones, wrote of “astral” or “zodiacal” stones: gems believed to be mystically tied to a sign.
What never existed is one agreed list. The birthstone chart the US jewelry trade keeps goes by calendar month, not by sign. So every zodiac chart you find is somebody’s list, and the honest thing is to say whose.
Three old lists, side by side
The chart above sets out the three we can trace to a printed source.
- Kunz’s verses (1913). A short rhyme for each sign, from Aquarius and its garnet to Capricorn and its ruby, by an author Kunz doesn’t name. The International Gem Society gives the same twelve stones today, sign for sign. In the charts we read, a stone called the “traditional” zodiac birthstone almost always comes from this list.
- Agrippa’s table (1533). Heinrich Cornelius Agrippa’s Three Books of Occult Philosophy, revised and printed in 1533, has a table of things that come in twelves. One row is the signs, another twelve stones, so each sign gets the stone in its column.
- The Spanish list (1604). Kunz quotes it from a book on the virtues of gems by Morales, printed in Valladolid, and thought it “probably represents Arab tradition.” It gives Taurus two stones, ruby and diamond, and leaves Pisces blank.
No two of the three give any sign the same stone. That’s how loose the tradition is.
Why charts online disagree
Many of the charts we read follow none of the three lists above. They take the modern birthstone of the month most of a sign’s days fall in: diamond for Aries, because most Aries birthdays are in April, emerald for Taurus, pearl for Gemini. The chart’s last row shows those months for every sign, so you can see where each answer comes from.
A third family of charts comes from India. In the navaratna, the traditional nine-gem setting, each gem stands for a heavenly body of Indian astrology: ruby for the Sun, pearl for the Moon, emerald for Mercury, coral for Mars, yellow sapphire or topaz for Jupiter, diamond for Venus and blue sapphire for Saturn. Charts that give each sign a planet’s gem lean on the old astrological idea that every sign is the “house” of a planet, as Ptolemy set it out in the second century: Leo the Sun’s, Cancer the Moon’s, Aries and Scorpio Mars’s, and so on. That is why a Leo can be told ruby on one site and onyx on another.
Zodiac stone or birthstone?
There’s no rule, so it comes down to what you like and what you’ll wear. A birthstone has the weight of a list most jewelers know; a zodiac stone is more personal, and it gives people born on either side of a month line a stone in common. The sign pages set each sign’s stones side by side, with their colors.
The signs and the stars
The signs are dates, not the stars behind them. Each one starts when the Sun reaches a set point of the year, and since the equinoxes come about six hours later each year and jump back a day in leap years, the first and last day of a sign can move by a day.
The stars have drifted, too. Because Earth’s axis slowly wobbles, the spring equinox that once had the Sun in Aries now has it in Pisces, and the Sun spends about 18 days a year in Ophiuchus, a constellation the twelve signs leave out. The zodiac stones belong to the signs, so none of this changes them.
A zodiac you could wear
The signs and stones met early. The J. Paul Getty Museum has a sard about 1.4 centimeters across, engraved in Italy in the first century BC with Victory driving a chariot and framed by a band with all twelve signs of the zodiac. Sard is a brownish cousin of carnelian, both of them chalcedony.